An Unusual Origin of An Ulnar Nerve From A Median Nerve- A Case ReportCorrespondence Address :
Chander Niwas, 61, Lawrence Road,
Amritsar â€“ 143001, Punjab, INDIA
Variations in the formation of brachial plexus are common and have been reported by several investigators in relation to origin of roots, trunks, cords, divisions and branches. The nerves of the extremities are especially vulnerable to injury because of their long course and superficial distribution. The basic anatomy of median and ulnar nerves in the upper limb is well described in the textbooks. Previously, an ample amount of work has been done upon the communications between the median and ulnar nerves in the forearm and hand. In the present case, an unreported pattern was seen where whole of the ulnar nerve was arising from the median nerve in the arm during routine under graduate dissections, in left upper limb of a 60 year old male. Its phylogeny and clinical implications are discussed in detail. A lack of awareness of variations might complicate surgical repair and may cause ineffective nerve blockade.
Ulnar nerve, Median Nerve, Brachial plexus, Communication
The arm is particularly vulnerable to neurological injury due to an intimate anatomical relationship between the brachial plexus and the traction zones. The brachial plexus has two fixed points, an upper one at the vertebrae and a lower one at the axillary fascia. During surgery, the combination of the arm abduction and the contralateral rotation of the head increases the stretch on the brachial plexus. Similarly, the posterior positioning of the abducted arm creates a considerable traction on it (1). Kroll et al (2) (1990) found ulnar neuropathies to be the most frequent causes of nerve injury litigations for pain, suffering and financial losses (33%), followed by brachial plexus injuries, which represented 23% of all the nerve injuries. The risk factors which are attributed to such injuries include abnormal posture, anaesthetic agents (1), spinal analgesia, prolonged hospitalization, neuropathies and the last but the most important one, the anatomical anomalies.
Apart from the surgeons, the variations in the nerves which supply the upper limb are of interest, not only to the radiologists who interpret plain computerized imagings and MRI and anesthesiologists who place needles in the neck to administer anaesthetic blocks, but also to the neurosurgeons, neurologists, vascular surgeons and orthopaedic surgeons (3).
According to the standard textbooks of Anatomy, in the lower axilla, the cords of the brachial plexus divide into the nerves of the upper limb. The ulnar nerve arises as a branch of the medial cord, but it often receives fibres from the lateral root of the median nerve. On the other hand, the median nerve is formed by the union of the lateral and the medial roots of the median nerve, arising from the lateral and the medial cords of the brachial plexus respectively.
During routine under graduate dissections in the left, upper limb of a 60 year old male, the medial cord was found to be formed normally by the fusion of the anterior divisions of C8 and T1. After its formation, instead of dividing into the medial root of the median nerve and the ulnar nerve, it bifurcated into the medial root of the median nerve and the medial cutaneous nerve of the forearm. The medial root of the median nerve fused with the lateral root of the median nerve (from the lateral cord) to form median nerve. After a course of 4 cm, the median nerve bifurcated into the median nerve proper and the ulnar nerve. The rest of the course and the branches of the median nerve and the ulnar nerve were normal. No other muscular or neurovascular anomaly was seen in this limb. The contralateral limb showed no anomaly (Table/Fig 1).
Many variational patterns of the branches of the brachial plexus have been described earlier. These include the communication between the median nerve and the musculocutaneous nerve (4); the absence of the posterior cord, merging of all the cords to form a single cord (5); the ulnar nerve arising from the posterior cord (6); and the communication between the median and the ulnar nerves (7).
An anomalous median-to-ulnar forearm communication, which is known as the Martin-Gruber anastomosis, has been well reported in the literature, while the Marinacci communication, the reverse of the Martin-Gruber anastomosis, with a forearm ulnar-to-median communication, has been under-recognized (8). However, none of the authors have commented upon a variation where the whole of the ulnar nerve arose from the median nerve, as in the present case.
Phylogeny Miller (9) (1934) summarized the work which was done by earlier authors on the brachial plexus in amphibians, reptiles, birds, monotremes, dogs, primates in general and in anthropoid apes. Heobserved that in animals with poorly developed hand structures, the ulnar and the median nerves were undifferentiated and that a single nerve trunk supplied the region. This condition is especially marked in the wing of the bird. In reptiles, the two nerves are formed from the trunk, although at a distance, peripherally. The actual differentiation of the ulnar nerve is evident in the monotremes and marsupials, in which the forelimbs are better developed and have a greater range of action. Conversely, the nerves to the compressed forefeet of dogs are fused or anastomosed for a greater part of their extent. The differentiation of the separate ulnar and median nerves are more definite in higher animals with well developed forelimbs. The pattern which was observed in the present case was similar to the patterns which were usually observed in lower animals like reptiles and dogs.
The anomalies at the high humeral level of the brachial plexus may present as a complicating factor during a surgical attempt to cause a nerve blockade. At high humeral levels, the median nerve descends from the axilla in close proximity to the brachial artery, frequently lying just lateral to the artery. Likewise, the ulnar nerveremains close to the artery to this point and is especially found just medial to the artery (10).
But in a case like ours, when the ulnar nerve originates at a distal level from the median nerve; an attempted ulnar nerve block at a proximal level may fail or an attempted median nerve blockade may result in an associated ulnar nerve blockade.
An effective brachial plexus blockade requires a thorough understanding of the anatomy of the plexus, as well as an appreciation of the anatomical variations that may occur. Variant nerve communications may cause ineffective nerve blockade and also, the blockade of unexpected areas. During a surgical procedure, such variations may lead to possible complications. Therefore, it is very important to know all the variants of the brachial plexus for a successful regional nerve blockade and operations.
- Emerging Sources Citation Index (Web of Science, thomsonreuters)
- Index Copernicus ICV 2017: 134.54
- Academic Search Complete Database
- Directory of Open Access Journals (DOAJ)
- Google Scholar
- HINARI Access to Research in Health Programme
- Indian Science Abstracts (ISA)
- Journal seek Database
- Popline (reproductive health literature)